The Deepening Social Care Crisis in Scotland

Scotland is facing a deepening social care crisis. With an aging population and rising demand for care services, the social care system is under immense strain. This article examines the key issues contributing to the crisis and puts forward potential solutions.


Social care refers to services that support people who are elderly, disabled, or have mental health problems. This includes help with everyday tasks like dressing, washing, meals, and mobility. Social care services in Scotland are provided by local authorities and private/voluntary organizations.

The social care sector has been chronically underfunded for years. Spending per person on social care in Scotland is lower than in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland. Successive governments have failed to prioritize social care funding. This has left the system creaking under the pressure of rising demand.

Key Factors Driving the Crisis

Demographic Changes

The biggest driver of increased social care demand is Scotland’s aging population. People over 65 make up 18% of the population, projected to rise to 25% by 2041. As people get older, more develop chronic illnesses and disabilities requiring social care.

Scotland also has high rates of “co-morbidities” i.e. people suffering from multiple long-term conditions. Caring for these groups is more complex and costly.

Workforce Shortages

Recruiting and retaining enough social care staff is an ongoing struggle. 6.5% of roles in the sector are vacant. Some key factors behind shortages include:

  • Poor pay and conditions: average pay is just £9.79 per hour. High workloads and stress lead to burnout.
  • Negative perceptions of social care as low-status work.
  • Brexit reducing EU immigration which traditionally supplied lots of care staff.
  • Competition from other sectors like retail/hospitality.

Funding Pressures

While demand has risen, real-terms funding has fallen over the last decade. The Scottish Government’s social care budget fell by 6% between 2013/14 and 2019/20. Local authority budgets have seen even deeper cuts.

At the same time, costs have risen with the introduction of the real Living Wage and need to invest in training and equipment. Care providers are under financial strain.

Impacts of the Crisis

The social care crisis is negatively impacting care quality and access. Key impacts include:

  • Older people not getting the care they need – over 35,000 on waiting lists for care services.
  • Increased pressure on unpaid carers, many of whom are elderly or disabled themselves.
  • Care services being cut back – e.g. home visits reduced to 15 minutes.
  • Providers going bust or handing back contracts.
  • Disabled adults waiting years for suitable accommodation.
  • Bed blocking in hospitals due to lack of social care provision.

The crisis also has economic costs through increased NHS spending and lost tax revenue/productivity from unpaid carers leaving work.

Potential Solutions

There are no quick fixes to resolve such a deep-rooted and complex crisis. However, some possible measures that could alleviate the situation include:

  • Increased central government funding – Experts estimate around £500-600 million more is needed annually. This could come from higher taxes or re-allocating budgets.
  • Reforming the care model – Shifting towards more home/community-based care and prevention. Investing in re-ablement services to maintain independence.
  • Workforce development – Better pay, training, career progression to attract and retain staff. Some role substitution with other professionals could help too.
  • Promoting technology – Such as robotics, telecare, apps to support care provision and independence.
  • Integration of health and social care – Breaking down silos between services to improve co-ordination and use resources more strategically.
  • Rethinking how care is funded – Moving beyond the current means-tested system towards universal/free personal care.


The social care crisis poses a huge challenge for Scotland. Tough decisions will need to be made on funding, eligibility and models of care. However, with political will and joint working between central/local government, providers and communities, solutions can be found. Taking action now will benefit many vulnerable people.

Leave a comment